Präsentation zum Thema: "…to enhance classroom talk tomorrow"— Präsentation transkript:
1…to enhance classroom talk tomorrow 7 ideas today…What are the persistent issues faced by languages teachers, and what approaches can we use/how can we meet these challenges head on?Taking as an immediate point of departure a secure understanding of what Ofsted wants to see in the languages classroom, and drawing on relevant research and other recent documentation, Rachel will outline a model of languages teaching guaranteed to raise teacher confidence about the lessons they deliver and how these improve learning…to enhance classroom talk tomorrowRachel Hawkes
2teacher talk student to student planned tasks Classroom talkOfsted urges languages teachers to “put greater emphasis on regular use of the target language in all lessons.” Research shows that it is more than simply a question of ‘using’ the target language more - teachers using TL does not necessarily result in learners using it. BUT there is also no doubt in my mind that we can’t expect learners to use the TL unless we as teachers are using it! This session explores practical, reliable and replicable strategies teachers can use to enhance the quality of the talk in their classrooms, including increasing the amount of spontaneous learner talk. We can identify 4 aspects of classroom talk to attend to in our work as languages teachers.student to teacherplanned tasks
31 Teacher talk – 5Cs Consistent Clear / concise Communicative Checks understandingCreative1. Consistent Absolutely vital. If you use the TL one day and not the next, you erode its effectiveness. If you use the TL and then translate yourself, you reduce its effectiveness. Consistency in TL use by the teacher involves planning, even scripting, and certainly thinking through each task / each explanation / each feedback and anticipating the language that you can use to communicate the meaning effectively to learners without resorting to English. If, at the planning stage, you realise that the message you need to give is vital but that you cannot conceive of how to do it in TL (or that doing it would take 20 minutes instead of 1) then you are justifying the use of English for that explanation / message. This is not the same for each teacher and it should be something we can all make progress in, such that we grow our use of TL and get more able to use it for a greater range of teaching activities. One teacher in my department, who has been working on this hard for 6 years, is currently challenging herself to 100% TL with a beginner Y8 German class. I observed and videoed several lessons at the start of the year and I’ve only seen her use English once for the word ‘exception’ which came up unexpectedly and she couldn’t immediately think how to convey its meaning clearly in the TL. 2. Clear / concise Using the TL makes us consider v carefully the words we use to explain things and the bring in additional non-verbal support mechanisms too, such as visuals, mimes, props, gestures. At the very beginning we will need to be very concise indeed. And the words that we do need to teach as TL in the course of our explanations will be incredibly useful language and should be flagged up in the lesson. One method for this that works effectively is to arrive at a class understanding of the word through teacher TL explanation, example, miming etc.. and then to ask a class member to provide the English meaning orally. The teacher only writes down the German and the students write down both (but still having to think rather than just copy down the English). On the next slide I have an example of the words that have come up in this way over the first half-term of German lessons (2 x lessons per week). 3. Checks understandingOf course we all use expressions to check understanding in our classrooms. But sometimes we don’t perhaps put enough emphasis on the expectation for a reply! I’ve often heard ‘Alles klar?’ by the teacher or ‘Entendéis?’ said almost as a rhetorical utterance. When there is barely a murmur in response, the teacher has not followed this up. if we think of the purpose of saying ‘ Is that clear?’ it seems really important that we accompany it with an expectation that students will either say confidently ‘Ja’ or will have questions because they are not clear about it. We have a couple of legendary stories in our department about this. In one class of lower ability learners one Y11 student, who had had the same teacher throughout Y10 too, and was used to his teacher saying to the class ‘Entendéis?’ suddenly asked her at Easter of Y11 – Miss, what is this about 10 days? What is going to happen in 10 days? You’ve been saying that since the start of Y10! So it’s a salient lesson that we need to ensure that we check understanding, of crucial terms and also of our teacher talk, especially key terms that we are going to repeat and repeat. Having said that, checking understanding also involves seeing how students respond. If they do what we ask readily, if the work produced matches expectations, then we can also be confident that they have understood. 4. Creative With the still limited language of our learners, teachers have to be creative about TL use. We will need to use cognates at the start (but also withdraw them as soon as we can if there is a better TL word) – I can think particularly of Moglichkeit in German rather than Possibilitat. If we first teach Possibilitat and then we introduce them to Moglichkeit we can then stop using possibilitat fairly soon. To get meanings across we will also need our ingenuity. Getting into the habit of using examples to get meanings across is invaluable, especially if they involve the immediate setting of the classroom. Referring to things that are too far removed from the classroom can lose beginner students. I watched a teacher come up with a very good way to tell her learners in lesson one that she wanted to know their preferred names, not just their register names, by using a member of the class who she imagined would prefer Kate rather than Kathryn. In this, as in other aspects of teacher talk, we can grow our ability. 5. Communicative Keeping it real. This doesn’t necessarily mean having a conversation with learners that is ‘off-topic’ although it can be nice to do this occasionally. It means responding to unplanned talk or learner questions in terms of the message rather than slipping into accuracy mode and correcting every utterance. This is very much about clarity of purpose for each activity. If you are practising pronunciation in a given task, then correct pronunciation errors. If you are practising producing correct forms e.g. perfect tense, then correct errors. But in every lesson there must be a decent chunk of time allocated to communicating through the TL. In these sorts of activities, where communication of the message is dominant, correction of errors is an unhelpful addition, because it blurs the purpose and demotivates the learner who is actually trying to really tell you about his/her pet. That doesn’t mean that as the teacher you don’t recognise that when Jimmy is talking he still hasn’t got the idea of where to put the adjective in French when he speaks spontaneously, but that doesn’t mean he wouldn’t know if he had time to plan to write or plan to speak. What we can do accurately in an unplanned situation is different to what we can do when we have time to reflect. And research is unclear at best about what a learner can take from explicit accuracy feedback while they’re in the act of talking. So if you notice in spontaneous speaking that there are fundamental errors, make a note that some more practice activities are needed down the line, but don’t stop him mid-flow. Only signal problems if they are genuine communication problems – i.e. you don’t know what he means. Then ask follow up questions to try to get to the meaning. Smile as you do this and encourage further communication. Offer alternatives to see if you can arrive at what he wanted to say.
42 Incidental talkHave a routine for recording the incidental talk that arises in everyday classroom interaction.
6Was ist richtig? Ich lese/spreche ein Buch Deutsch ist danke/gut Ich bin intelligent/ein HeftMathe ist einfach/jetztUsain Bolt laüft sehr fast/schnellIch habe keine/nein BrüderPhysik ist schwierig/jaIntegrating incidental classroom talk with curriculum language.
7teacher talk student to student planned tasks student to teacherplanned tasks
83 PhonicsStudents will be more confident at speaking in the target language if they have a secure grasp of the sound/writing relationship.
104 Question wordsStudents can initiate in the classroom as soon as they know the individual question words, so teach these with gestures asap!
11¿Cómo? ¿Con quién? ¿Dónde? ¿Qué? ¿Quién? ¿Cuándo? ¿Por qué?¿Con quién?¿Dónde?¿Qué?¿Quién?Teach the question words with gestures.¿Cuándo?
12¿Qué pregunta es? ¿Dónde? Juego al fútbol. ? en Comberton. Using the Q words in context to reinforce their meaning. Lines 1 – 3 are there. Students supply the question word orally. Do a couple first to model, then give each pair 20 seconds to say each dialogue first before taking the answer whole class for the rest of the slides.
13¿Qué pregunta es? ¿Cuándo? Juego al fútbol. ? el sábado. Using the Q words in context to reinforce their meaning. Lines 1 – 3 are there. Students supply the question word orally. Do a couple first to model, then give each pair 20 seconds to say each dialogue first before taking the answer whole class for the rest of the slides.
14¿Qué pregunta es? ¿Cómo? ¿Qué? Juego al fútbol. ? ¡JUEGO AL FÚTBOL! Using the Q words in context to reinforce their meaning. Lines 1 – 3 are there. Students supply the question word orally. Do a couple first to model, then give each pair 20 seconds to say each dialogue first before taking the answer whole class for the rest of the slides.
15¿Qué pregunta es? Juego al fútbol. ? ¡Es fenomenal! ¿Por qué? Using the Q words in context to reinforce their meaning. Lines 1 – 3 are there. Students supply the question word orally. Do a couple first to model, then give each pair 20 seconds to say each dialogue first before taking the answer whole class for the rest of the slides.
16¿Qué pregunta es? ¿Con quién? Juego al fútbol. ? con mis amigos. Using the Q words in context to reinforce their meaning. Lines 1 – 3 are there. Students supply the question word orally. Do a couple first to model, then give each pair 20 seconds to say each dialogue first before taking the answer whole class for the rest of the slides.
175 Teach it!Interaction language needs teaching. Introduce key structures and encourage students to use and re-use them often.
18teacher talk student to student planned tasks student to teacherplanned tasks
196 Spontaneity is planned! What is spontaneous for the students can be planned for by the teacher! Incorporate a range of different tasks into lessons that require students to produce language off the top of their heads.https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=Swan+paddling&client=firefox-a&hs=Fr4&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&tbm=isch&source=iu&imgil=6b30GtTr3awV4M%253A%253Bhttps%253A%252F%252Fencrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com%252Fimages%253Fq%253Dtbn%253AANd9GcRlgG8to7yBKEw6u1vMEJgS7nrx6nqGO6J6zrdi51O1HSmQzTOm%253B300%253B203%253BG4EDnEfmU6sNUM%253Bhttp%25253A%25252F%25252Fwww.themusicjungle.co.uk%25252Flive%25252F2011%25252F09%25252F03%25252Fno-more-swans-please%25252F&sa=X&ei=_LrjUrnXBtCa0QXTjIGwDg&ved=0CD8Q9QEwAg&biw=1920&bih=976#facrc=_&imgdii=_&imgrc=6b30GtTr3awV4M%253A%3BG4EDnEfmU6sNUM%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.themusicjungle.co.uk%252Flive%252Fwp-content%252Fuploads%252F2011%252F09%252Fswan-copy2.png%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.themusicjungle.co.uk%252Flive%252F2011%252F09%252F03%252Fno-more-swans-please%252F%3B300%3B203
21¿Qué programas te gustan? Your answer must contain EXACTLY 7 words!¿Qué programas no te gustan?The conditions or ‘targets’ can be many and varied. It ALMOST doesn’t matter as the point of putting a condition there is to cause students to think their sentences through carefully as they build them. It makes them much more aware of what they’re saying. And making a sentence of exactly 8 words will involve usually a very short clause with ‘weil’ or two clauses linked with ‘und’ or additional details like when and where. So they focus on different ways to make their sentences longer. It also works well to set >9 words or <5 words at times too.Your answer must contain more than 9 words!21
23Salut. Je m’appelle Clarisse et j’habite à Fonainebleau Salut! Je m’appelle Clarisse et j’habite à Fonainebleau. Je suis drôle et intelligente et je suis fan de foot! Le foot, c’est ma passion. Mon équipe, c’est le PSG. Mon frère Rény est très sympa. En genéral on s’entend bien et normalement on regarde les matches de foot ensemble. Hier soir, j’ai regardé un match de foot international à la télé, J’ai mangé du popcorn, comme d’hab. Le weekend dernier, je suis allée au Parc des Princes où j’ai regardé le PSG contre Auxerre. J’ai aimé le match parce qu’il y a eu deux pénalties. Après le match, je suis allée au café où j’ai mangé un sandwich.❶❷❸Text taken from Studio 2 – Heinemann course. Module 3 unit 5. p.56❹
241Comment t’appelles tu?2Où habites-tu?3Tu es comment?4Tu es drôle? Tu es intelligent?5Quel est ton sport préféré?6Quelle est ta passion?7Quelle est ton équipe préférée?8Qui est Rény?9Tu as des frères ou des soeurs?10Comment s’appelle ton frère?11Ton frère, il est comment?12On se dispute?13Qu’est-ce qu’on fait ensemble?14Qu’est-ce que tu aimes faire avec ton frère?
2515Qu’est-ce que tu fais normalement avec ton frère?16Qu’est-ce que tu as fait hier soir?17Tu as mangé quelquechose?18Qu’est-ce que tu as fait le weekend dernier?19Le PSG, c’est quoi?20C’était bien le match? Pourquoi?21Le PSG a gagné?22Qu’est-ce que tu as fait après le match?
277. Oui, mais c’est un peu ennuyeux. ¿Quelles sont les questions?7. Oui, mais c’est un peu ennuyeux.1. J’adore le sport.2. Quinze ans.6. Oui, bien sûr. Et toi?3. À Cambridge.5. Oui, j’aime beaucoup.4. Oui.27
28Busca a la persona que… juega al fútbol los sábados. va al cine a menudo.lee todos los días.ve la tele cada día.nunca descarga música del Internet.
29teacher talk student to student planned tasks student to teacherplanned tasks
307 Creating contextsTeach specific language e.g. for game playing or for group talk tasks and then keep creating opportunities for students to use it.
31Du bist ein großer Schwindler / eine große Schwindlerin! You are a big cheater!Halt die Klappe! Ich höre nicht.Shut up! I can’t hear.Ich habe gewonnen! Ich bin der Meister / die Meisterin!I have won! I am the champion!Was hast du für Nummer geschrieben?What have you written for number ....?Du hast verloren!You have lost!Ich habe keine Ahnung, kannst du mir helfen?I have no clue, can you help me?Fang an! Du bist daran!Start! It’s your turn!Können wir bitte zusammen arbeiten, ich verstehe das nicht so gut?Can we work together please, I don’t understand it very well..Example from Hinchingbrooke School – one of the 12 schools involved in the TL project They have decided to teach explicitly 8 x TL phrases for Teacher talk, Student to Teacher talk and Student to Student talk. They’ve made v clear the different purposes and registers of these 3 x different sets of talk. The students make themselves cards (TL on one side and English on the other) and some teachers get the students to lay them out English side up at the start of the lesson and they have to try and use as many of them as possible by the end.
32Pilla al intruso Nadal Paella David Villa Andy Murray This is not so much a starter as the main part of the lesson. It is their first introduction to odd one out tasks and they need to understand how they work and why they’re so valuable. This is perhaps also a useful lesson to have a longer, more detailed look with learners at the progress tracking docs in their booklets. There are boxes for them to shade for NC level progress (3 per skill per level to allow for cumulative build-up) and also for the wider skills (memory etc..) – they should be encouraged to think about where they are in terms of these and to shade in too. This discussion should provide a really useful starting point for this activity, where they will be creative (generating ideas and risk-taking), reasoning, (analysing, decision-making, justifying, categorising and making links), empthatic (speaking & listening & responding), active (noticing). Make reference to the L2L chart to show how much they will be doing here.
33¡Sí, es verdad! ¡No, es mentira! ¡Yo también! ¡Yo tampoco! ¿Qué piensas?Pienso que...¡Sí, es verdad! ¡No, es mentira!¡Yo también! ¡Yo tampoco!XXXYear 7 Talking frame¡Estás loco/a!¿Qué piensas?33
34Es (from verb ‘SER’ to be) It is (permanent characteristics) Pienso que…I think that…Creo que..I believeLa excepción es..the exception isporquebecause/forEs (from verb ‘SER’ to be)It is (permanent characteristics)un animal – una persona - un país – un continente -an animal – a person - a country – a continentde Inglaterra, Escocia, España…plural/singularun verbo – un adjetivo – un sustantivoa verb - an adjective - a nounmasculino - femeninomasculine - femininediferentedifferentlos otros son…the others are…This is a simplified support sheet for Odd one out – it includes only the verb SER as this has been the focus so far. In the next Odd One Out lesson we will use TENER, ESTAR and Hay too. There is space left for them to write this in in a future OOO lesson.
35Pilla al intruso A B C D España Perú Brasil Cuba Madrid Paris Londres BarcelonaCyoellanosotrosUstedThis is not so much a starter as the main part of the lesson. It is their first introduction to odd one out tasks and they need to understand how they work and why they’re so valuable. This is perhaps also a useful lesson to have a longer, more detailed look with learners at the progress tracking docs in their booklets. There are boxes for them to shade for NC level progress (3 per skill per level to allow for cumulative build-up) and also for the wider skills (memory etc..) – they should be encouraged to think about where they are in terms of these and to shade in too. This discussion should provide a really useful starting point for this activity, where they will be creative (generating ideas and risk-taking), reasoning, (analysing, decision-making, justifying, categorising and making links), empthatic (speaking & listening & responding), active (noticing). Make reference to the L2L chart to show how much they will be doing here. Also, give them the help sheet and go through it AND also encourage them that there are NO single right answers – there may be lots of different correct answers!Dunodosdiezdoce
36And finally…Involve the students in reflecting on their own TL use and the teacher TL use. Ask them regularly to give their impressions as to their own progress.
37Project: Classroom talk Questionnaire:(write the answers in the back of your book, we will compare them each half term to see if the % increases)How much German does your teacher speak in the classroom (% of total speech)?How much German do you use when talking to your teacher (% of total speech)?How much German do you use when talking to other students (% of total speech)?This format for gathering student input / reflections was shared by Jane Driver at a recent ALL South Cambs meeting.
38Secret policeman Someone in the class is the secret policeman. They will take note of who uses the German classroom phrases the most.At the end of the class, the secret policeman will reveal him/herself.The person using them the most German phrases will receive a reward at the end of the class.
39Ich brauche noch eine Minute I need another minute Nochmal, bitte Es ist männlichIt’s masculineEs ist weiblichIt’s feminineEs ist andersIt’s differentEs ist vielfachIt’s pluralEs endet mit ....It finishes withEs beginnt mitIt starts withIch weiß es nichtI don’t knowIch verstehe nichtI don’t understandIch brauche noch eine MinuteI need another minuteNochmal, bitteAgain, pleaseIch habe mein Heft / Tagebuch vergessenI have forgotten my exercise book / plannerWie sagt man auf Englisch / Deutsch?How do you say …. in English / German?Student – Teacher (also to student) phrases The idea of this lesson is for the students to learn vocabulary in pairs – this is a good time to have a discussion and remind them of techniques for vocabulary learning (total focus, short bursts, repetition, etc..). Hand out a sheet to each student and get them to cut them into flashcards. Put them in pairs and give them 15 minutes to learn as many of the phrases as possible – the idea is that the pair who can memorize the most wins – once we have taught this lesson, as a teacher, it is imperative that you do not accept these phrases from students in English anymore – at the end of the lesson they should either glue them or save them into their books in an envelope – 25 mins
40http://www. all-languages. org Rachel Hawkes (Presentations and Training Speaking) My profile on TES:My