Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated.

Präsentation zum Thema: "Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated."—  Präsentation transkript:

1

2 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 1 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Immissionsprognose Luft Gutachtenprüfung Wolfgang J.Müller Bucharest February 2006

3 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 2 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Diese Anforderungen an ein Gutachten gelten für jedes Immissionsprognose Modell !

4 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 3 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Gliederung 1.Einleitung 2.Anforderungen an gutachterliche Stellungnahmen 3.Prüfung von Gutachten 4.Fazit

5 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 4 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects 1. Einleitung Grundlage zur Feststellung und Beurteilung von Luftschadstoffen bei Anlagen ist die TALuft Für die Immissionsprognose Anhang 3 der TALuft Und …..

6 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 5 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects 2. Anforderungen an gutachterliche Stellungnahmen Grundlagen TALuft Anforderungen des LAI an Messstellen (Gutachter) für Emissionsmessungen VDI / DIN Richtlinien Es ist nicht ausreichend diese nur aufzuzählen!

7 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 6 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Beschreibung der Aufgabenstellung Vollständige Messplanung Beschreibung des tatsächlichen Ablaufs der Messung Bei Abweichung von anerkannten Messverfahren oder Verwaltungsvorschriften detaillierte Begründung erforderlich Messwertauflistung 2. Anforderungen an gutachterliche Stellungnahmen Allgemeine Anforderungen

8 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 7 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Darstellung der Auswerteverfahren Qualitätssicherungsmaßnahmen Namentliche Benennung des Berichterstatters und der beteiligten Personen Aufgabenstellung und Bewertung der Ergebnisse müssen aufeinander abgestimmt sein Verwaltungsrechtliche Bewertung obliegt der Behörde 2. Anforderungen an gutachterliche Stellungnahmen Allgemeine Anforderungen

9 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 8 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Emissionsgutachten (E-Messberichte) Immissionsgutachten (I-Messberichte) Immissionsprognosegutachten (I-Prognose) 3. Prüfung von Gutachten 3 verschiedene Gutachten bilden das Team der Immissionsprognose

10 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 9 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Prüfung von Emissionsgutachten Formulierung der Messaufgabe - Vollständige Beschreibung der Aufgabenstellung - Darstellung der aufgabenbezogenen Sachprobleme Die Aufgabe muss mit den im Gutachten beschriebenen Mitteln von Dritten nachvollzogen werden können. Anlagenbeschreibung - Beschreibung der relevanten Anlagenteile inkl. Emissions- quellen und Einrichtungen zur Erfassung und Minderung der Emissionen - Betriebs- bzw. Emissionszeiten der Anlage - Betriebszustand der Anlage während der Messung

11 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 10 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Messergebnisse - Plausibilitätsprüfung der Messergebnisse - Ergebnisse vergleichbarer Anlagen vorhanden? - Liegen die Ergebnisse im erwarteten Bereich? - Weisen die Abluftrandparameter Unplausibilitäten auf? Prüfung von Emissionsgutachten Unter Berücksichtigung der genannten Prüf- und Beurteilungspunkte ist dann zu entscheiden, ob das Gutachten bzw. der Messbericht plausibel ist.

12 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 11 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Immissionsgutachten Als Grundlage der Vorbelastung der Immission Als Bestimmung der Emissionsquellstärke bei diffusen Emissionsquellen Als Prüfung der Zusatzbelastung durch die neue Quelle

13 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 12 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Prüfung von Immissionsprognosegutachten Einsatzgebiete: - beliebige Entfernungsbereiche - einzelne Quellen oder Viel-Quellensysteme - ebenes oder komplexes Gelände Ziel: Prognose der vorhandenen und/oder zu erwartendenSchadstoffbelastung Immissionsprognosen

14 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 13 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Schematischer Ablauf einer Immissionsprognose: Aufbereitung für die Ausbreitungs- rechnung Ausbreitungs- rechnung Transmission Bewertung der Ergebnisse Ergebnis Ausbreitungs -rechnung Immission Daten- sammlung Emission

15 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 14 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Prüfung von Immissionsprognosegutachten Die bisher genannten Anforderungen an gutachterliche Stellungnahmen sind auch hier zu berücksichtigen. - Vollständige Beschreibung der Aufgabenstellung - Darstellung der aufgabenbezogenen Sachprobleme Die Aufgabe muss mit den im Gutachten beschriebenen Mitteln von Dritten nachvollzogen werden können. Notwendige Basisinformationen

16 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 15 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects - Emissionsdaten aus zitierten Messberichten oder einschlägiger Literatur - Bewertung der verwendeten Daten -Rückschlüsse auf andere Anlagen belegen - Entsprechen die Quellen den Anforderungen der TA Luft? Emissionsbegrenzungen, Schornsteinhöhe, Ableitung Über Dach -Frühere Gutachten zur betrachteten Anlage sind zu benennen Datensammlung Die im Gutachten verwendeten Daten sind eindeutig ihrer Herkunft nach zu kennzeichnen und ihrer Auswahl nach zu bewerten.

17 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 16 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Eingangsdaten für die Ausbreitungsrechnung Die korrekte Überführung der gesammelten Daten in die Eingangsdatei der Ausbreitungsrechnung ist von entscheidender Bedeutung! Eine detaillierte sachgerechte Prüfung der Eingangsdaten zur Immissionsprognose ist nur mit ausreichender Fachkenntnis über das verwendete Ausbreitungsmodell möglich. Aber die notwendige Vorprüfung kann auch die Genehmigungsbehörde durchführen !

18 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 17 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Emissionsdaten/-faktoren Emissionsmassenstrom Abgasvolumen inkl. Bezugsangabe (feucht/trocken) Abgasgeschwindigkeit Wärmestrom /Abgastemperatur Quellhöhe und räumliche Ausdehnung der Quelle Lage der Emissionsquellen (Lageplan) Eingangsdaten für die Ausbreitungsrechnung

19 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 18 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Eingangsdaten Meteorologie Herkunft des Datensatzes Standort (Koordinaten) Anemometerhöhe Umgebung Einflußfaktoren Zeitliche Repräsentativität des Datensatzes Räumliche Repräsentativität Übertragbarkeit auf Anlagenstandort geprüft ?

20 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 19 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects 1.Ist die Station für die Ausbreitungsverhältnisse im Rechengebiet repräsentativ ? 2. Werden die lokalen Windsysteme von der Station ausreichend berücksichtigt ? 3. Werden die zu erwartenden Hauptwindrichtungen von der Station genügend genau wiedergegeben ? 4. Welche Methode wurde zur Übertragung der meteorologischen Daten einer Station auf das Rechengebiet verwendet? z. B. nach Kolb, FITNAH, METRAS Eingangsdaten Meteorologie

21 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 20 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Quelle:argusoft

22 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 21 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Z 0 Rauigkeitslänge Die Datenbankinternen (CORINAIR) örtlichen Zuweisungen sind mit der Realität zu vergleichen und ihre sachgerechte Anwendung ist zu prüfen

23 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 22 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Die Turbulenzerzeugung aufgrund der Bodenrauigkeit wird durch die Rauigkeitslänge z0 beschrieben. Die Rauigkeitslänge liegt etwa zwischen 1/10 und 1/20 der Hindernishöhe.

24 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 23 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Klas se z 0 in m Nutzung nach CORINE–Kataster 10,01Strände, Dünen und Sandflächen; Wasserflächen 20,02Deponien und Abraumhalden; Wiesen und Weiden ; Natürliches Grünland; Flächen mit spärlicher Vegetation; Salzwiesen; Gewässerläufe; Mündungsgebiete 30,05Abbauflächen; Sport– und Freizeitanlagen; Nicht bewässertes Ackerland; Gletscher und Dauerschneegebiete 40,10Flughäfen; Sümpfe; Torfmoore; Meere und Ozeane 50,20Straßen, Eisenbahn; Städtische Grünflächen; Weinbauflächen; Komplexe Parzellenstrukturen; Landwirtschaft und natürliche Bodenbedeckung; Heiden und Moorheiden; Felsflächen ohne Vegetation 60,50Hafengebiete; Obst– und Beerenobstbestände; Wald–Strauch– Übergangsstadien 71,00Nicht durchgängig städtische Prägung; Industrie– und Gewerbeflächen; Baustellen; Nadelwälder 81,50Laubwälder; Mischwälder 92,00Durchgängig städtische Prägung Rauigkeitsklassierung nach TALuft

25 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 24 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects z 0 Verteilung, Beispiel

26 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 25 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects InputDatei Austal2000 Meteorologie Aufpunktraster Rauigkeitslänge (CORINE-Kataster) Qualitätsstufe

27 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 26 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Ausbreitungsprogramm mit Versionsnummer (AUSTAL2000) Aussagen zum Anwendungsbereich des Modells (z.B. Gebäudeumströmung) Den Einsatz des Ausbreitungsmodells begleitende, qualitätssichernde Maßnahmen Ausbreitungsrechnung Zur der Ausbreitungsrechnung sind u.a. folgende Angaben erforderlich:

28 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 27 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Ergebnisse der Ausbreitungsrechnung Ergebnisdarstellung: Darstellung der Berechnungsergebnisse in tabellarischer Form (Beurteilungsflächen, Monitorpunkte) Graphische Darstellung der Berechnungsergebnisse mit Beurteilungsflächen Einfache, erste Plausibilitätsprüfung mit der Windrichtungsverteilung der verwendeten Meteorologie

29 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 28 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Bewertung der Ergebnisse der Ausbreitungsrechnung Sind die allgemeinen Anforderungen an Gutachten erfüllt? Sind alle genannten Punkte vom Gutachter zufriedenstellend abgearbeitet worden? Erscheinen die ermittelten Ergebnisse plausibel? Nach Abarbeitung der genannten Prüf- und Beurteilungspunkte ist dann zu entscheiden, ob das Gutachten plausibel ist.

30 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 29 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Immissions prognose gutachten

31 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 30 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects 4. Fazit Auf die Einhaltung der allgemeinen Anforderungen an Gutachten ist zu achten! Die Prüfung von Immissionsprognosegutachten erfordert Sach- und Fachkenntnis. Die Dokumentation der angewendeten Vorgehensweise als auch einzelner Arbeitsschritte ist im Rahmen der Qualitätssicherung unbedingt notwendig. Die vom Gutachter erzeugten Ergebnisse müssen durch Dritte reproduzierbar sein.

32 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 31 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Austal2000 Thanks for your attention

33 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 32 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Air Pollution Dispersion Calculation Industry Wolfgang J. Müller Former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology

34 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 33 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Overview Basic Stack height Gauss vs. Lagrange model TA Luft – AUSTAL2000 Meteorology Example Preassessment Remarks

35 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 34 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects First General Administrative Regulation Pertaining the Federal Immission Control Act Technical Instructions on Air Quality Control – TA Luft 1. October 2002 Basic: TA Luft new Licensing procedure guideline for fullfilling EU Guidelines Air Quality

36 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 35 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects First step: Check stack height

37 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 36 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Source strength Exhaust volume = f ( Mieteneigenschaften,... Betreiber (Management),.... Meteorologie...) EMISSION Point source or diffusive source ?

38 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 37 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Low stack height High stack TRANSMISSION Distance from Source

39 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 38 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects D= 1.5 m T= 80 Grad C R= 60000m 3 /h Q/S (kg/h) 24 kg /h 0.08 = 300 H = 55 m plus x m for developed areas Stack height – Nomogram TA Luft / Q/S =

40 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 39 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects PM SO 2 TALuft, Annex 7, Tab. 22 Adjust !?

41 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 40 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Gauß Model TALuft 1986 AUSTAL86

42 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 41 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Restrictions of GAUSS Model Wind- and Turbulence fields are homogeneous in space and time Flat, homogeneous terrain Constant source strength invalid by calm, low windspeed Statistic of Dispersion Classes Dispersion parameters by experiments Dispersion coefficients valid in the range approx. 100 m ----------------------10 km Results:Annual Mean Value, 98% Percentile

43 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 42 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Lagrange Partikelmodell VDI 3945 Blatt 3 include Physical processes : Transport by the mean wind Dispersion in the Atmosphäre Dry Deposition Chemical process of 1. Order thermal & mechanical impuls (plume rise)

44 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 43 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Lagrange Model system new model system

45 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 44 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects 0…….80 s.................... 240 s later Emission 1000 Particles in H=100 m Calculation of Concentration by mass of particle of each cell volume Distance from source (m)

46 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 45 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Transformation of EU Guideline Air Quality in National law and TALuft Components: NO 2, SO 2, Benzene, PM10, Tetrachlorethen, Hydrogenfluoride, Ammonia Heavy metals … Ambient air concentration and deposition Timescales: annual mean, daily mean, and hourly mean with exceedence frequencies per year

47 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 46 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Check of Dispersion Calculation Report Process flow Preparation for Calculation Dispersion Calculation Transmission Evaluation of results Results of Calculation Ambient air Data- Collection Inputdata Emission, Meteo Orography Buildings

48 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 47 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects AUSTAL2000 Next generation dispersion model Most flexibel approach with respect to Meteorology Terrain, Orography Wind flow around buildings Use of meteorological time series Proved in practice since 16 years

49 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 48 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Advantage vs. Gauss model concept Timeseries of emission Timeseries of Meteorology Profile of winddirection, velocity depending of height Roughness length Terrain, orography Chemical transformation 1. Order

50 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 49 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Instationary dispersion situation Timeseries and statistics of meteo data all kinds of Point-, line-, area- and volume- sources Calculation of shorttime and longterm concentrations Monitoring of hourly values at monitoring sites Advantages of AUSTAL2000

51 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 50 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects AUSTAL2000 Free software (GNU license) Programm and software source code Based on System LASAT, Janicke commercial software package www.austal2000.de

52 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 51 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Odour Dispersion Calculation included ! Model system

53 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 52 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Meteo Input data Winddirection in the height of anemometer Windvelocity in the height of anemometer Turbulence describing parameters: Monin- Obukhov Length Boundary layer height Roughness length describing the turbulence production by soil roughness Displacement height Dispersion Class as used before.

54 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 53 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Mean Roughness Length Subject to the Land Cover Indicated in the CORINE Land Cover Inventory Tab. 14 Annex 3 TALuft

55 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 54 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Z 0 Roughness length Displacement Height d Forest: z 0 = 1,5 m Displacement Height d= 6*z 0 = 9, 0 m Windprofile u~ ln (z)

56 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 55 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Corine Land Cover http://www.corine.dfd.dlr.de

57 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 56 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Z 0 = 0.77mR=2 km

58 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 57 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Meteo Data File Structure Timeseries *.akt * AKTERM-Zeitreihe, Deutscher Wetterdienst, Offenbach (KB1A) * Zeitraum 01/1999 bis 12/1999 * anonymisierte Daten, Stand: 11.04.2002 + Anemometerhoehen (0.1 m): 32 41 57 74 98 144 200 244 283 Station Direction Year Velocity n/10 (m/s) Month Dispersion Class Day Mixing Height Time AK 10999 1999 01 01 00 00 1 1 150 29 1 2 1 -999 9 AK 10999 1999 01 01 01 00 1 1 130 31 1 2 1 -999 9 AK 10999 1999 01 01 02 00 1 1 130 33 1 2 1 -999 9 AK 10999 1999 01 01 03 00 1 1 130 35 1 3 1 -999 9 AK 10999 1999 01 01 04 00 1 1 140 30 1 2 1 -999 9

59 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 58 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects TRANSMISSION Wind Direction Distribution (1 year in %)

60 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 59 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects R= 50 * H, xi,yi c> 3% Limit Value Year ? X,Y max. concentration additional load selection of 2 measuring sites area of calculation AUSTAL2000

61 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 60 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Monitor point hourly timeseries gas Immission

62 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 61 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Nesting of grid cell

63 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 62 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects ti Project1-2006 qs -2 az anno96.akterm hq 60 z0 0.5 so2 2.2 no2 4.5 no 3.4 pm-1 4.7 pm-2 4.7 Title Quality stage Data file meteo Quellhöhe (m) Roughness length SO2-emission in g/s NO2-emission in g/s NO-emission in g/s Dust emission(d < 2.5 µ) Dust emi (2.5 < d < 10 µ) Input data

64 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 63 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Log data file/ data file of Results AUSTAL2000 2004-04-22 17:39:02 START ….. =========================== Beginn der Eingabe ========================== > ti "0305 Tierhaltung Ohne" 'Projekt-Titel Title > gx 3384360.00 'X-Koordinate des Bezugspunktes Reference Coordinate > gy 5794920.00 'Y-Koordinate des Bezugspunktes Reference Coordinate > z0 0.50 'Rauhigkeitslänge roughnesslength > qs 0 'Qualitätsstufe quality stage > as "E:\Meteorology\Austal2000\osnabrueck_91-00.aks" 'AKS-Datei meteodatafile > ha 10.00 'Anemometerhöhe (m) > dd 30 'Zellengröße (m) cellgrid > x0 -413.8 'X-Koordinate der l.u. Ecke des Gitters (coordinate 0,0) > nx 30 'Anzahl Gitterzellen in X-Richtung number of grid cells > y0 -319.0 'Y-Koordinate der l.u. Ecke des Gitters (coordinate 0,0) ny 26 'Anzahl Gitterzellen in Y-Richtung number of grid cells ………. Check in detail is possible !!

65 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 64 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Particle size depending calculation of PM: ambient air concentration and deposition Calculation of deposition of Ammonia (Nitrogen) Chemical transformation of NO to NO 2 Calculation of 3- dimension Windfield in the case of terrain and building Advantages of AUSTAL2000

66 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 65 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Next steps in Romania: Use of AUSTAL2000, source code available, free of charge Data format transformation of meteo data for AUSTAL2000 Automatic roughness length calculation adoption training

67 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 66 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Example – Screening methods preassessment air quality Collect, summerize emissions Compare with National, EMEP Inventory…. What stack height is needed ? Are emission data reliable? Calculate air conconcentration by AUSTA2000 model, Compare with passive sampler and…

68 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 67 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects 1. Simulation of annual mean Concentration

69 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 68 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Calculated Time series (hourly) at Monitoring Point 1

70 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 69 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Remarks 1.You need persons, who are mainly involved in dispersion calculation ! 2.You have to reinforce these persons for checking dispersion calculation reports ! 3.These persons have to build up a knowledge center for all kinds of dispersion calculation questions in accordance to the EU Guideline of Air Quality

71 Wolfgang J.Müller STE; former Lower Saxony State Agency for Ecology Bucharest, 21 st to 23 rd of February 2006 Component 4: Operational Duties, Integrated Permitting Procedure Activity 4.3: Establishment of an Integrated Permitting Procedure, Application of BAT Mission 41-1: Workshop – Presentation of the Manual on Integrated Permitting Procedure 70 EU-Twinning Project RO2004/IB/EN-09 Implementation and Enforcement of the Environmental Acquis at National Level and Coordination of 8 Regional Twinning Projects Thanks for your attention ! …